Review Desk engineering-documentreview
ENNL
Demo door PitchAI · alleen synthetische gegevens - fictief project, fictieve bedrijven, geen echte projectdocumentenGeen product van een projecteigenaar. De engineer beslist; de agents stellen voor.
NCT-PKG-003 · ronde 1 · run 9d8ce9bbb27f

Audit trail

Reviewbureau
done
20 Oct 2026 11:29:00 UTC · 229 s
306
gelogde eistoetsen
61
gelogde verificatiebesluiten
46
modelaanroepen · 111,573 tokens

Gebruikte model(len): LongCat 2.5 (free fallback model). Elk event wordt met tijd opgeslagen; besluiten van de engineer worden hieronder toegevoegd zodra ze genomen worden.

Events

11:29:00runrun gestart · 10 documenten · 152 eisen
11:29:00intakeRequirements register: 152 requirements (48 with a deterministic rule, 104 checked by discipline agents); 25 documents in the project document register.
11:29:00intakeNCT-CIV-DW-0801_A.dxf - DXF, 54 kB, sha256 ff7bc5a810bd
11:29:00intakeNCT-INS-DS-0101_A.xlsx - XLSX, 7 kB, sha256 e3b6985afca0
11:29:00intakeNCT-INS-IL-0501_A.xlsx - XLSX, 6 kB, sha256 1cbd1099c023
11:29:01intakeNCT-MEC-PR-0701_A.docx - DOCX, 39 kB, sha256 7b69172a7412
11:29:01intakeNCT-MEC-SP-0201_A.docx - DOCX, 39 kB, sha256 28957ca73a9e
11:29:01intakeNCT-PIP-CA-0601_A.pdf - PDF, 5 kB, sha256 99133f6ace9e
11:29:01intakeNCT-PIP-LL-0401_A.xlsx - XLSX, 6 kB, sha256 b58d991ac8d1
11:29:01intakeNCT-PRC-PID-0301_A.dxf - DXF, 54 kB, sha256 cbc4de7da4f7
11:29:01intakeNCT-PRC-PID-0302_C1.dwg - DWG, 25 kB, sha256 75e3f70895d3
11:29:01intakeNCT-QAC-ITP-0901_A.pdf - PDF, 5 kB, sha256 50c4e4ed027e
11:29:01reader:cadOpening NCT-CIV-DW-0801_A.dxf with the CAD reader
11:29:01reader:excelOpening NCT-INS-DS-0101_A.xlsx with the Excel reader
11:29:01reader:excelOpening NCT-INS-IL-0501_A.xlsx with the Excel reader
11:29:01reader:wordOpening NCT-MEC-PR-0701_A.docx with the Word reader
11:29:01reader:wordOpening NCT-MEC-SP-0201_A.docx with the Word reader
11:29:01reader:pdfOpening NCT-PIP-CA-0601_A.pdf with the PDF reader
11:29:01reader:excelOpening NCT-PIP-LL-0401_A.xlsx with the Excel reader
11:29:01reader:cadOpening NCT-PRC-PID-0301_A.dxf with the CAD reader
11:29:01reader:cadOpening NCT-PRC-PID-0302_C1.dwg with the CAD reader (DWG converted to DXF by LibreDWG dwg2dxf)
11:29:01reader:pdfOpening NCT-QAC-ITP-0901_A.pdf with the PDF reader
11:29:02reader:excelNCT-INS-DS-0101 Rev A: 47 passages, 1 tables, 3 tags, 0 references, language EN.
11:29:02reader:excelNCT-INS-IL-0501 Rev A: 22 passages, 1 tables, 11 tags, 24 references, language EN.
11:29:02reader:excelNCT-PIP-LL-0401 Rev A: 16 passages, 1 tables, 5 tags, 7 references, language EN.
11:29:03reader:pdfNCT-PIP-CA-0601 Rev A: 40 passages, 0 tables, 0 tags, 9 references, language EN.
11:29:03reader:pdfNCT-QAC-ITP-0901 Rev A: 30 passages, 0 tables, 0 tags, 14 references, language EN.
11:29:03reader:cadNCT-PRC-PID-0302: 22 entities on 8 layers; title block PROJECT=NORTH COAST CO2 TRUNKLINE (FICTIONAL), DOCNO=NCT-PRC-PID-0302, TITLE=P&ID LANDFALL VALVE STATION, REV=C1, DATE=2026-09-17, STATUS=IFR; 0 dimensions; 5 tags.
11:29:03reader:cadDWG converted with LibreDWG dwg2dxf 0.14; 25 handle issues repaired by the DXF auditor.
11:29:03reader:wordNCT-MEC-PR-0701 Rev A: 40 passages, 0 tables, 0 tags, 3 references, language NL.
11:29:03reader:cadNCT-PRC-PID-0301: 45 entities on 8 layers; title block PROJECT=NORTH COAST CO2 TRUNKLINE (FICTIONAL), DOCNO=NCT-PRC-PID-0301, TITLE=P&ID COMPRESSOR DISCHARGE AND PIG LAUNCHER, REV=A, DATE=2026-09-16, STATUS=IFR; 0 dimensions; 12 tags.
11:29:03reader:cadNCT-CIV-DW-0801: 37 entities on 8 layers; title block PROJECT=NORTH COAST CO2 TRUNKLINE (FICTIONAL), DOCNO=NCT-CIV-DW-0801, TITLE=PLOT PLAN COMPRESSOR STATION, REV=A, DATE=2026-09-21, STATUS=IFR; 3 dimensions; 0 tags.
11:29:03reader:wordNCT-MEC-SP-0201 Rev A: 56 passages, 0 tables, 4 tags, 4 references, language EN.
11:29:03crossCross-checking P&ID and datasheet tags against instrument index NCT-INS-IL-0501 and P&ID line numbers against line list NCT-PIP-LL-0401.
11:29:0313NCT-CIV-DW-0801: 24 eisen via matrix
11:29:03applicabilityNCT-CIV-DW-0801 (layout drawing): 24 of 152 requirements apply via the matrix - 11 rule checks, 13 to discipline agents, who confirm applicability per requirement.
11:29:0319NCT-INS-DS-0101: 35 eisen via matrix
11:29:03applicabilityNCT-INS-DS-0101 (datasheet): 35 of 152 requirements apply via the matrix - 16 rule checks, 19 to discipline agents, who confirm applicability per requirement.
11:29:033NCT-INS-IL-0501: 14 eisen via matrix
11:29:03applicabilityNCT-INS-IL-0501 (instrument index): 14 of 152 requirements apply via the matrix - 11 rule checks, 3 to discipline agents, who confirm applicability per requirement.
11:29:0322NCT-MEC-PR-0701: 35 eisen via matrix
11:29:03applicabilityNCT-MEC-PR-0701 (procedure): 35 of 152 requirements apply via the matrix - 13 rule checks, 22 to discipline agents, who confirm applicability per requirement.
11:29:0335NCT-MEC-SP-0201: 51 eisen via matrix
11:29:03applicabilityNCT-MEC-SP-0201 (specification): 51 of 152 requirements apply via the matrix - 16 rule checks, 35 to discipline agents, who confirm applicability per requirement.
11:29:0314NCT-PIP-CA-0601: 28 eisen via matrix
11:29:03applicabilityNCT-PIP-CA-0601 (calculation): 28 of 152 requirements apply via the matrix - 14 rule checks, 14 to discipline agents, who confirm applicability per requirement.
11:29:036NCT-PIP-LL-0401: 21 eisen via matrix
11:29:03applicabilityNCT-PIP-LL-0401 (line list): 21 of 152 requirements apply via the matrix - 15 rule checks, 6 to discipline agents, who confirm applicability per requirement.
11:29:0315NCT-PRC-PID-0301: 31 eisen via matrix
11:29:03applicabilityNCT-PRC-PID-0301 (P&ID): 31 of 152 requirements apply via the matrix - 16 rule checks, 15 to discipline agents, who confirm applicability per requirement.
11:29:0315NCT-PRC-PID-0302: 31 eisen via matrix
11:29:03applicabilityNCT-PRC-PID-0302 (P&ID): 31 of 152 requirements apply via the matrix - 16 rule checks, 15 to discipline agents, who confirm applicability per requirement.
11:29:0317NCT-QAC-ITP-0901: 25 eisen via matrix
11:29:03applicabilityNCT-QAC-ITP-0901 (inspection and test plan): 25 of 152 requirements apply via the matrix - 8 rule checks, 17 to discipline agents, who confirm applicability per requirement.
11:29:11agent:Mechanicalmodelaanroep · check NCT-INS-DS-0101 (2 req.) · LongCat 2.5 (free fallback model) · 2189 + 102 tokens · 3.57 s
11:29:11agent:Quality, HSE & document controlmodelaanroep · check NCT-INS-DS-0101 (1 req.) · LongCat 2.5 (free fallback model) · 2120 + 26 tokens · 3.93 s
11:29:13agent:Process & pipingmodelaanroep · check NCT-INS-DS-0101 (3 req.) · LongCat 2.5 (free fallback model) · 2215 + 156 tokens · 5.52 s
11:29:15agent:Quality, HSE & document controlmodelaanroep · check NCT-CIV-DW-0801 (8 req.) · LongCat 2.5 (free fallback model) · 2139 + 338 tokens · 8.07 s
11:29:17agent:Quality, HSE & document controlmodelaanroep · check NCT-INS-IL-0501 (1 req.) · LongCat 2.5 (free fallback model) · 2391 + 26 tokens · 2.71 s
11:29:25agent:Quality, HSE & document controlmodelaanroep · check NCT-MEC-PR-0701 (6 req.) · LongCat 2.5 (free fallback model) · 2382 + 182 tokens · 6.07 s
11:29:25agent:Instrumentationmodelaanroep · check NCT-INS-DS-0101 (5 req.) · LongCat 2.5 (free fallback model) · 2293 + 282 tokens · 10.87 s
11:29:26agent:Process & pipingmodelaanroep · check NCT-MEC-PR-0701 (4 req.) · LongCat 2.5 (free fallback model) · 2285 + 152 tokens · 5.31 s
11:29:28agent:Instrumentationmodelaanroep · check NCT-INS-IL-0501 (2 req.) · LongCat 2.5 (free fallback model) · 2436 + 347 tokens · 12.34 s
11:29:34agent:Quality, HSE & document controlmodelaanroep · check NCT-MEC-SP-0201 (5 req.) · LongCat 2.5 (free fallback model) · 2647 + 114 tokens · 4.05 s
11:29:36agent:Mechanicalmodelaanroep · check NCT-MEC-PR-0701 (8 req.) · LongCat 2.5 (free fallback model) · 2756 + 331 tokens · 7.44 s
11:29:39agent:Mechanicalmodelaanroep · check NCT-MEC-PR-0701 (4 req.) · LongCat 2.5 (free fallback model) · 2410 + 247 tokens · 10.77 s
11:29:41agent:Process & pipingmodelaanroep · check NCT-MEC-SP-0201 (2 req.) · LongCat 2.5 (free fallback model) · 2488 + 77 tokens · 4.12 s
11:30:04agent:Instrumentationmodelaanroep · check NCT-INS-DS-0101 (8 req.) · LongCat 2.5 (free fallback model) · 2436 + 194 tokens · 56.98 s
11:30:11agent:Instrumentationmodelaanroep · check NCT-MEC-SP-0201 (2 req.) · LongCat 2.5 (free fallback model) · 2471 + 48 tokens · 2.88 s
11:30:13agent:Mechanicalmodelaanroep · check NCT-MEC-SP-0201 (8 req.) · LongCat 2.5 (free fallback model) · 2770 + 180 tokens · 29.71 s
11:30:17agent:Mechanicalmodelaanroep · check NCT-MEC-SP-0201 (2 req.) · LongCat 2.5 (free fallback model) · 2468 + 202 tokens · 31.55 s
11:30:19agent:Quality, HSE & document controlmodelaanroep · check NCT-PIP-CA-0601 (3 req.) · LongCat 2.5 (free fallback model) · 2204 + 75 tokens · 4.29 s
11:30:21agent:Quality, HSE & document controlmodelaanroep · check NCT-CIV-DW-0801 (5 req.) · LongCat 2.5 (free fallback model) · 1983 + 351 tokens · 14.44 s
11:30:21agent:Quality, HSE & document controlModel answer for check NCT-CIV-DW-0801 (5 req.) was incomplete; 5 complete result(s) kept, the rest stays unchecked.
11:30:24agent:Process & pipingmodelaanroep · check NCT-PIP-CA-0601 (8 req.) · LongCat 2.5 (free fallback model) · 2449 + 240 tokens · 7.36 s
11:30:25agent:Process & pipingmodelaanroep · check NCT-PIP-CA-0601 (3 req.) · LongCat 2.5 (free fallback model) · 2189 + 227 tokens · 5.21 s
11:30:28agent:Process & pipingmodelaanroep · check NCT-MEC-SP-0201 (8 req.) · LongCat 2.5 (free fallback model) · 2813 + 657 tokens · 56.46 s
11:30:30agent:Quality, HSE & document controlmodelaanroep · check NCT-PIP-LL-0401 (1 req.) · LongCat 2.5 (free fallback model) · 1850 + 26 tokens · 7.83 s
11:30:31agent:Quality, HSE & document controlmodelaanroep · check NCT-PRC-PID-0301 (3 req.) · LongCat 2.5 (free fallback model) · 2236 + 70 tokens · 3.08 s
11:30:32agent:Mechanicalmodelaanroep · check NCT-MEC-SP-0201 (8 req.) · LongCat 2.5 (free fallback model) · 2815 + 345 tokens · 52.32 s
11:30:34agent:Process & pipingmodelaanroep · check NCT-PRC-PID-0301 (8 req.) · LongCat 2.5 (free fallback model) · 2466 + 195 tokens · 5.28 s
11:30:34agent:Process & pipingmodelaanroep · check NCT-PIP-LL-0401 (5 req.) · LongCat 2.5 (free fallback model) · 2052 + 316 tokens · 8.87 s
11:30:35agent:Process & pipingmodelaanroep · check NCT-PRC-PID-0301 (1 req.) · LongCat 2.5 (free fallback model) · 2128 + 26 tokens · 3.37 s
11:30:40agent:Instrumentationmodelaanroep · check NCT-PRC-PID-0301 (3 req.) · LongCat 2.5 (free fallback model) · 2213 + 94 tokens · 5.54 s
11:30:40agent:Process & pipingmodelaanroep · check NCT-PRC-PID-0302 (1 req.) · LongCat 2.5 (free fallback model) · 1587 + 59 tokens · 2.82 s
11:30:41agent:Instrumentationmodelaanroep · check NCT-PRC-PID-0302 (3 req.) · LongCat 2.5 (free fallback model) · 1672 + 99 tokens · 3.16 s
11:30:47agent:Quality, HSE & document controlmodelaanroep · check NCT-QAC-ITP-0901 (8 req.) · LongCat 2.5 (free fallback model) · 2378 + 315 tokens · 7.8 s
11:30:47agent:Process & pipingmodelaanroep · check NCT-QAC-ITP-0901 (3 req.) · LongCat 2.5 (free fallback model) · 2148 + 98 tokens · 3.07 s
11:30:53agent:Quality, HSE & document controlmodelaanroep · check NCT-QAC-ITP-0901 (5 req.) · LongCat 2.5 (free fallback model) · 2240 + 522 tokens · 8.89 s
11:30:53agent:Quality, HSE & document controlModel answer for check NCT-QAC-ITP-0901 (5 req.) was incomplete; 10 complete result(s) kept, the rest stays unchecked.
11:31:17agent:Mechanicalmodelaanroep · check NCT-QAC-ITP-0901 (1 req.) · LongCat 2.5 (free fallback model) · 2048 + 186 tokens · 32.07 s
11:31:42agent:Quality, HSE & document controlmodelaanroep · check NCT-PRC-PID-0302 (3 req.) · LongCat 2.5 (free fallback model) · 1695 + 75 tokens · 7.46 s
11:31:42agent:Quality, HSE & document controlModel answer for check NCT-PRC-PID-0302 (3 req.) was incomplete; 3 complete result(s) kept, the rest stays unchecked.
11:32:15agent:Process & pipingmodelaanroep · check NCT-PRC-PID-0302 (8 req.) · LongCat 2.5 (free fallback model) · 1925 + 1257 tokens · 39.19 s
11:32:15agent:Process & pipingModel answer for check NCT-PRC-PID-0302 (8 req.) was incomplete; 8 complete result(s) kept, the rest stays unchecked.
11:32:19verifiermodelaanroep · challenge NCT-MEC-PR-0701 · LongCat 2.5 (free fallback model) · 2159 + 71 tokens · 3.56 s
11:32:19verifiermodelaanroep · challenge NCT-PIP-CA-0601 · LongCat 2.5 (free fallback model) · 1934 + 48 tokens · 3.87 s
11:32:20verifiermodelaanroep · challenge NCT-INS-IL-0501 · LongCat 2.5 (free fallback model) · 2369 + 49 tokens · 4.32 s
11:32:20verifiermodelaanroep · challenge NCT-CIV-DW-0801 · LongCat 2.5 (free fallback model) · 1648 + 76 tokens · 4.37 s
11:32:20verifiermodelaanroep · challenge NCT-INS-DS-0101 · LongCat 2.5 (free fallback model) · 2051 + 74 tokens · 4.59 s
11:32:20verifiermodelaanroep · challenge NCT-MEC-SP-0201 · LongCat 2.5 (free fallback model) · 2611 + 136 tokens · 5.26 s
11:32:24verifiermodelaanroep · challenge NCT-QAC-ITP-0901 · LongCat 2.5 (free fallback model) · 2282 + 122 tokens · 5.36 s
11:32:29verifiermodelaanroep · challenge NCT-PIP-LL-0401 · LongCat 2.5 (free fallback model) · 1822 + 41 tokens · 10.58 s
11:32:29verifier53 candidate findings: 0 dropped because the quote is not in the document, 8 rejected by the second opinion, 5 merged as duplicates; 40 findings go to the engineer.
11:32:50finalrun klaar · 40 open bevindingen
11:32:55engineerbesluit engineer: bevinding #181 → approved (High)
11:32:56engineerbesluit engineer: bevinding #186 → approved (Medium)
11:32:57engineerbesluit engineer: bevinding #198 → rejected (Low)
11:32:58engineerbesluit engineer: bevinding #182 → approved (High)

Modelaanroepen

AgentDoelModelinouts
agent:Mechanicalcheck NCT-INS-DS-0101 (2 req.)LongCat 2.5 (free fallback model)21891023.6
agent:Quality, HSE & document controlcheck NCT-INS-DS-0101 (1 req.)LongCat 2.5 (free fallback model)2120263.9
agent:Process & pipingcheck NCT-INS-DS-0101 (3 req.)LongCat 2.5 (free fallback model)22151565.5
agent:Quality, HSE & document controlcheck NCT-CIV-DW-0801 (8 req.)LongCat 2.5 (free fallback model)21393388.1
agent:Quality, HSE & document controlcheck NCT-INS-IL-0501 (1 req.)LongCat 2.5 (free fallback model)2391262.7
agent:Quality, HSE & document controlcheck NCT-MEC-PR-0701 (6 req.)LongCat 2.5 (free fallback model)23821826.1
agent:Instrumentationcheck NCT-INS-DS-0101 (5 req.)LongCat 2.5 (free fallback model)229328210.9
agent:Process & pipingcheck NCT-MEC-PR-0701 (4 req.)LongCat 2.5 (free fallback model)22851525.3
agent:Instrumentationcheck NCT-INS-IL-0501 (2 req.)LongCat 2.5 (free fallback model)243634712.3
agent:Quality, HSE & document controlcheck NCT-MEC-SP-0201 (5 req.)LongCat 2.5 (free fallback model)26471144.0
agent:Mechanicalcheck NCT-MEC-PR-0701 (8 req.)LongCat 2.5 (free fallback model)27563317.4
agent:Mechanicalcheck NCT-MEC-PR-0701 (4 req.)LongCat 2.5 (free fallback model)241024710.8
agent:Process & pipingcheck NCT-MEC-SP-0201 (2 req.)LongCat 2.5 (free fallback model)2488774.1
agent:Instrumentationcheck NCT-INS-DS-0101 (8 req.)LongCat 2.5 (free fallback model)243619457.0
agent:Instrumentationcheck NCT-MEC-SP-0201 (2 req.)LongCat 2.5 (free fallback model)2471482.9
agent:Mechanicalcheck NCT-MEC-SP-0201 (8 req.)LongCat 2.5 (free fallback model)277018029.7
agent:Mechanicalcheck NCT-MEC-SP-0201 (2 req.)LongCat 2.5 (free fallback model)246820231.6
agent:Quality, HSE & document controlcheck NCT-PIP-CA-0601 (3 req.)LongCat 2.5 (free fallback model)2204754.3
agent:Quality, HSE & document controlcheck NCT-CIV-DW-0801 (5 req.)LongCat 2.5 (free fallback model)198335114.4
agent:Process & pipingcheck NCT-PIP-CA-0601 (8 req.)LongCat 2.5 (free fallback model)24492407.4
agent:Process & pipingcheck NCT-PIP-CA-0601 (3 req.)LongCat 2.5 (free fallback model)21892275.2
agent:Process & pipingcheck NCT-MEC-SP-0201 (8 req.)LongCat 2.5 (free fallback model)281365756.5
agent:Quality, HSE & document controlcheck NCT-PIP-LL-0401 (1 req.)LongCat 2.5 (free fallback model)1850267.8
agent:Quality, HSE & document controlcheck NCT-PRC-PID-0301 (3 req.)LongCat 2.5 (free fallback model)2236703.1
agent:Mechanicalcheck NCT-MEC-SP-0201 (8 req.)LongCat 2.5 (free fallback model)281534552.3
agent:Process & pipingcheck NCT-PRC-PID-0301 (8 req.)LongCat 2.5 (free fallback model)24661955.3
agent:Process & pipingcheck NCT-PIP-LL-0401 (5 req.)LongCat 2.5 (free fallback model)20523168.9
agent:Process & pipingcheck NCT-PRC-PID-0301 (1 req.)LongCat 2.5 (free fallback model)2128263.4
agent:Instrumentationcheck NCT-PRC-PID-0301 (3 req.)LongCat 2.5 (free fallback model)2213945.5
agent:Process & pipingcheck NCT-PRC-PID-0302 (1 req.)LongCat 2.5 (free fallback model)1587592.8
agent:Instrumentationcheck NCT-PRC-PID-0302 (3 req.)LongCat 2.5 (free fallback model)1672993.2
agent:Quality, HSE & document controlcheck NCT-QAC-ITP-0901 (8 req.)LongCat 2.5 (free fallback model)23783157.8
agent:Process & pipingcheck NCT-QAC-ITP-0901 (3 req.)LongCat 2.5 (free fallback model)2148983.1
agent:Quality, HSE & document controlcheck NCT-QAC-ITP-0901 (5 req.)LongCat 2.5 (free fallback model)22405228.9
agent:Mechanicalcheck NCT-QAC-ITP-0901 (1 req.)LongCat 2.5 (free fallback model)204818632.1
agent:Quality, HSE & document controlcheck NCT-PRC-PID-0302 (3 req.)LongCat 2.5 (free fallback model)1695757.5
agent:Process & pipingcheck NCT-PRC-PID-0302 (8 req.)LongCat 2.5 (free fallback model)1925125739.2
verifierchallenge NCT-MEC-PR-0701LongCat 2.5 (free fallback model)2159713.6
verifierchallenge NCT-PIP-CA-0601LongCat 2.5 (free fallback model)1934483.9
verifierchallenge NCT-INS-IL-0501LongCat 2.5 (free fallback model)2369494.3
verifierchallenge NCT-CIV-DW-0801LongCat 2.5 (free fallback model)1648764.4
verifierchallenge NCT-INS-DS-0101LongCat 2.5 (free fallback model)2051744.6
verifierchallenge NCT-MEC-SP-0201LongCat 2.5 (free fallback model)26111365.3
verifierchallenge NCT-QAC-ITP-0901LongCat 2.5 (free fallback model)22821225.4
verifierchallenge NCT-PIP-LL-0401LongCat 2.5 (free fallback model)18224110.6
leadsummaryLongCat 2.5 (free fallback model)115670020.3